Tuesday, August 26, 2025

Book Review: "The Travels of Ibn Battutah" (abridged)



Here's a game: using your place of birth as the center, how far west, east, north and south have you traveled on this planet? For me, the westernmost point is San Francisco, northernmost is Luleå (Sweden), easternmost is Moscow, and southernmost is Marrakesh.

Now think of people living in the 1330s. Who, in those days, was the most well-traveled person in history? The vast majority were born, lived and died within spitting distance of their birthplace. Who didn't? Marco Polo? Alexander the Great? Maybe a Chinese merchant traveling the Silk Road?

All signs indicate that the person was Ibn Battutah, a qadi (judge) who left his home town of Tangier, Morocco in 1325 and didn't stop traveling until 1354. What begins as a pilgrimage to Mecca by way of the Horn of Africa soon becomes a true globe-trotting journey, taking in the pyramids in Gizeh, Constantinople, the Arabian peninsula, and Central Asia, and then on to India, the Maldives, Sri Lanka, and further still, to Bangladesh, the islands of Sumatra and Java in Indonesia, and finally the east coast of China (then ruled by a descendant of Genghis Khan). But that's not all: after returning home, he goes on to visit Andalusia in Spain and travels all the way down to Timbuktu in Mali, where he meets Mansa Sulaiman, the brother of Mansa Musa, arguably the richest man who ever lived. (Of course, most of these places have different names in Ibn Battutah's day.)

Virtually everywhere he goes, there is a Muslim presence of some kind, and vast swaths of the ground he covers are ruled by Muslims. He generally gets a warm welcome by the local rulers, who are keen to hear his stories about distant lands, and receives enough horses, camels and slaves to make it to his next destination. And, miraculously, he survives everything, being none the worse for wear, escaping even the Black Death that is ravaging Europe when he's there.

Once home, he sits down and turns his experience into a manuscript that's 1000 pages long. The entire thing was translated in English in the 1950s, and a scan of all four volumes is online for free at the Internet Archive. (I've read only a 300-page abridged version.)

The story sounds almost too good to be true, and you'd have good reason to be skeptical: in Europe, one Sir John Mandeville, around the same time, wrote a travelogue filled with fantastical monsters, men with dog heads and cotton plants that grow sheep, and the Europeans eagerly ate up the baloney. 

But this is in sharp contrast with Ibn Battutah, who not only describes his itinerary so meticulously that there is a Google Map of his voyages, there's also a mere handful of cases where his claims cannot be corroborated by 21st-century scholars. He write cautiously, and his caution is understandable: his claims are scrutinized and criticized by scholars when he returns, even when he tells things that are verifiably true, say, that rulers in India throw handfuls of dirhams on the ground for their subjects to scramble over. He explains what hippos are, what a coconut is and how pepper is grown and dried.

Equally surprising, compared to the highly dramatic style of European books of the time, is his non-judgmental, objective and detached style: only very rarely does he express any kind of emotional reaction to people and customs that to him must have seemed perfectly alien. He reports his experiences with a neutrality that could make a present-day cultural anthropologist jealous.

In other words, the book is a contemporary portrait of the world in the Middle Ages (except for the Americas, of course) that is without equal. Maybe I'll eventually sink my teeth into the full, 1000-page version, but for now, I'll cherish the abridged and heavily annotated version.


Monday, May 26, 2025

Book review: "1491: New Revelations of the Americas Before Columbus" by Charles C. Mann

 StoryGraph link


A few years ago, I read an article in The New Yorker about a new kind of archeology: archeologists would fly in an airplane over a South American jungle, sending down continuous laser beams as they flew. Dense though the canopy may be, the little laser beams still managed to find the minuscule gaps between the leaves and send down their light to the landscape below, resulting in a 3D rendering of what lay hidden under the trees. The result was astounding: an entire overgrown civilization was concealed in the jungle, undiscovered for centuries, waiting for this breakthrough technology to find it.

This book is like that airplane: it reveals that many, indeed most, things we thought we knew about the Americas before Columbus now turn out to be false. The civilizations of the continent were considered static, underdeveloped and uniform, and this book shows them to be none of the three. After reading 1491, the Americas seem to me as alien as a faraway planet. Most of the population died out before the rest of the world had a decent opportunity to discover and explore it. Those deaths, the book argues, were much more numerous than we previously imagined (Mann quotes a 95% death rate in some areas) on the one hand, and also much less intentional than conventional wisdom assumes (most died of diseases they were completely unfamiliar with, rather than directly at the hands of European invaders).

Because of this massive loss of life, what we're left with are scraps and ruins, hints and clues about what was lost. From what we know, the Indians (a term preferred by many indigenous people over the stiffly PC "Native Americans") did almost everything so wildly differently from the rest of the world that outsiders were not even capable of recognizing the sophistication, subtlety or even existence of it.

A good example is agriculture. To Eurasians and Africans, this means cordoning off land, growing a crop on it, maybe letting animals graze on it, that sort of thing. To the original Americans, it means turning the Amazon rain forest into a gigantic garden, growing multiple plant species side by side (a technique called milpa) and using fire to control the land. Because this was an alien concept to the rest of the world, they mistook a giant stretch of agricultural land for untouched wilderness. In this way, the book also does away with the romantic notion of Indians living in some kind of New Age harmony with nature.

At the same time, it's also a big misconception to see the population of this giant continent as one homogenous group. Quite the contrary: in addition to the cultures most of us know, like the Inka, the Aztecs, the Olmecs and the Mayans, there were many more cultures I'd never heard of, like the Wari, for example, and other cultures whose names we'll never know. Some were bloodthirsty, brutal and warlike; others were peaceful, surviving under harsh conditions, or democratic to an extent that Europe was at that time unfamiliar with (and tried to suppress).

The most important, inescapable conclusion, is that Europe was, in many ways, the inferior culture. It may seem as if only superior firepower could explain how a handful of foreign invaders could subjugate an entire continent. But the reality was that that firepower was not nearly as superior as you might think, not to mention that Indians got their hands on some of those firearms themselves before long. Physically, the native population tended to be strong, muscular and imposing: they were horrified by the Spanish with their pockmarked faces. It was chicken pox and various other diseases that wiped out huge swaths of the population, often emptying a region even before the colonists caught up with the bugs.

Maybe you've come across the story of the passenger pigeon, a now-extinct pigeon species of which, at one point, there were a billion in the Americas. You'll probably have been told that this incredibly abundant bird (one in four birds in America were passenger pigeons at some point) went extinct due to deforestation and large-scale hunting. And that is all true.

But what's often left out of the story is the odd fact that the Indians before Columbus seem to have eaten very few passenger pigeons. When examining Indian sites, the bones of all kinds of animals can be found, but bones of these birds, despite their apparent abundance, were quite uncommon. How could this be? The shocking explanation is that before Columbus, passenger pigeons were not as abundant: they had large numbers of human predators. That all changed after the Europeans arrived: the mass deaths of the indigenous population paved the way for a population explosion of the bird.

We'll probably never know the real scale of the devastating loss that the "discovery" of the Americas brought about. But this book offers a glimpse, through stories like these. We owe it, not just to the lost peoples, but also to the world, to find out as much as we can about the people who lived in the Americas --even if that is very little.

Monday, May 19, 2025

JSLL #76 - The Spider's Thread, part 24

 Sentence:

この分でのぼって行けば、地獄からぬけ出すのも、存外わけがないかも知れません。

このぶんでのぼっていけば、じごくからぬけだすのも、ぞんがいわけがないかみしれません。

Vocabulary

  • 分 means "part, portion, share" but also "condition, extent, rate (as in 'at this rate, ...')"
  • 存外 means "beyond expectations, contrary to expectation, unexpectedly"
  • わけがない means "there's no way that..." or "easy, simple." わけ on its own means "reason, grounds, cause."
  • かも知れません, which is usually written only with kana, literally means "[I/you/someone] can't know whether..." but is invariably translated as "perhaps, maybe."
Kanji

Two new kanji: 存 is an N3 kanji in 18 common words. 外 is an N5 kanji in 84 words. The second kanji has a connotation/meaning of "outside, except, exception."

Translation

If he would climb at this rate, sneaking out of hell would perhaps be easier than expected.

Sunday, May 18, 2025

JSLL #75 - The Spider's Thread, part 23

It's a Sunday, so we'll do 2 sentences, with very few new words and only 1 new kanji.

Sentence 1:

すると、一生懸命にのぼった甲斐があって、さっきまで自分がいた血の池は、今ではもう暗の底にいつの間にかかくれて居ります。

すると、いっしょうけんめいにのぼったかいがあって、さっきまでじぶんがいたちのいけは、いまではもうやみのそこにいつのまにかかくれております。

Vocabulary

  • 甲斐 means "result (that makes an act worthwhile), worth (in doing something), value, effect, use, benefit, avail." 
  • いつの間にか means "before one knows, before one becomes aware of, unnoticed, unawares"
  • かくれる (usually written 隠れる) means "to hide, to conceal oneself, to take cover"
Kanji
The only new kanji is 斐 which is an N1 kanji that occurs in only 3 words, always preceded by 甲. The trendy Japanese concept of "ikigai" is 生き甲斐, where 生き comes from 生きる, "to live." So literally, "ikigai" means "reason to live."

Translation
Then, it had been worth climbing with all his might: the lake of blood where he had been until recently, had become hidden in the deep darkness before he had realized it.

Sentence 2:

それからあのぼんやり光っている恐ろしい針の山も、足の下になってしまいました。

それからあのぼんやりひかっているおそろしいはりのやまも、あしのしたになってしまいました。

And that terrible Mountain of Needles, too, shining dimly, had ended up under his feet.



Saturday, May 17, 2025

JSLL #74 - The Spider's Thread, part 22

 Sentence:

そこで仕方がございませんから、まず一休み休むつもりで、糸の中途にぶら下がりながら、遥かに目の下を見下ろしました。

そこでしかたがございませんから、まずひとやすみやすむつもろで、いとのちゅうとにぶらさがりながら、はるかにめのしたをみおろしました。

Vocabulary:

  • 中途 means "halfway, midway"
  • ぶら下がる means "to hang down (from), to be suspended, to dangle, to swing"
  • 遥かに means "far off, in the distance"
  • 見下ろす means "to overlook, to command a view of, to look down on"

Translation

Because it was pointless there, he first paused for a short breather, and then, while he was dangling halfway up the thread, he looked down at the view far below him.

Monday, May 12, 2025

JSLL #73 - The Spider's Thread, part 21

 It's slow going, but we're chipping away at this story. The second sentence of part three.

ややしばらくのぼる中に、とうとう犍陀多もくたびれて、もう一たぐりも上の方へはのぼれなくなってしまいました。

ややしばらくのぼるうちに、とうとうかんだたもくたびれて、もうひとたぐりもうえのほうへはのぼれなくなってしました。

Vocabulary

  • やや means "a little, partially, somewhat, slightly, semi-, -ish, on the X side, a short time, a while"
  • しばらく means "for a moment; for a while; for the time being"
  • 中 is here given with the uncommon reading うち rather than the more common なか. The word うち is typically written as 内. This is uncommon kanji use. The top meanings of this word are "inside, within; while, during, within, in the course of; among, between; in, amidst"
  • とうとう means "finally, at last"
  • くたびれる is an intranstivie verb that means "to get tired, to become worn out, to get tired of/fed up with"
Translation

After climbing for a little while, even Kandata finally grew tired, and in the end couldn't reel himself up any longer.

Saturday, May 10, 2025

JSLL #72 - The Spider's Thread, part 20

 We're entering part 3 of "The Spider's Thread" by Ukatagawa Ryousuke. Here's sentence 1 from that part.

Sentence:

しかし地獄と極楽との間は、何万里となくございますから、いくら焦ってみたところで、容易に上へは出られません。

しかしじごくとごくらくとのあいだは、なんまんりとなくございますから、いくるあせってみたところで、とうにうえへはでられません。

Vocabulary

  • 万 means "10,000." Unlike English which renews its counting after 3 zeroes (ten, hundred, thousand; ten thousand, hundred thousand, million; and so on), Japanese renews its counting after 4 zeroes: 十 (ten), 百 (100), 千 (1000), 万 (10,000), 十万 (100,000), 百万 (1,000,000), 千万 (10,000,000); and so on).
  • 里 is an old unit of measurement for distance, corresponding to roughly 4 km or 2.4 miles.
  • となく according to jisho.org "adds vagueness and indirectness to the word or phrase it is used with"
  • いくら means "how many, how much" or, in some context, "no matter how many, no matter how much"
  • 焦る means "to be in a hurry, to be impatient, to be anxious, to fret; to get a fright, to panic, to get flustered, to be startled." The second sense is given as "colloquial," so we can probably disregard it.
  • 容易 means "easy, simple, plain," but strangely, it's given both as a na-adjective and as a noun.
Kanji

Kanji

N-level

Occurs in how many common words?

N5

20

None, but a jouyou kanji

10

N1

4

N3

10


Translation

However, because the space between Hell and Heaven is many tens of thousands of kilometers, no matter how much you fret, you can't get up out of it.


Book Review: "The Travels of Ibn Battutah" (abridged)

Here's a game: using your place of birth as the center, how far west, east, north and south have you traveled on this planet? For me, th...